University of Cincinnati's head basketball coach Mick Cronin doesn't like ESPN.com's newest NCAA Tournament projections. ESPN's resident bracketologist Joe Lunardi has just seven Big East teams in the dance -- none of which are Cincinnati.Cronin didn't find it amusing. "I would tell Joe Lunardi he needs to buy the ESPN Full Court package. Are you telling me that Syracuse wouldn't win the A-10? Does somebody want to give me that answer? I'd like to have that argument with somebody.
"You're going to tell me that Syracuse, with their McDonalds's All-Americans and their talent, would not win the A-10? They're eighth in our conference. For us to not get at least eight is only a by-product of us beating up on each other and being penalized for having too good of a conference."
Those are the normal gripes from people who think the Big East deserves eight, nine or 10 spots in the tournament. It doesn't fly with me or, apparently, Lunardi.
Lunardi defended his position by telling him that he, not Cronin, knows the inner workings of how the selection committee crafts its bracket.
Now I don't know Cronin, and he appears to be doing a terrific job of keeping his Bearcats more than competitive in the hellacious Big East. But I would politely suggest that he keep his eye on the ball and leave broader judgments about the tournament selection process to the NCAA men's basketball committee, since apparently my views aren't to his liking.
Lunardi goes on to dismiss Cronin's complaints. The fact that anyone is eighth in the Big East is meaningless since the committee looks at individual teams and not conferences. He has had nine teams placed in his projections for most of the season, but Notre Dame and Georgetown have fallen off due to their amazing funks.
As for that comment about an eighth place Big East team would cruise through the Atlantic-10, Lunari points out that the lowest seeded Big East team has had a better seeding in the NCAA's than the A-10 champion just once in the past eight years. After all, likely Atlantic-10 champ Xavier did beat Cincinnati earlier this year. They also beat likely Conference USA champion Memphis and ACC bubble team Virginia Tech.
Lunardi also points out that Syracuse has continued to be in his projections, despite Cronin's complaint that they weren't.
As for Cronin's Bearcats, Lunardi points out that they are 0-6 against teams that are currently in his bracket. Those two wins over Georgetown don't look as good if the Hoyas are an N.I.T. team.
I side with Lunardi here. I don't think the Big East should get a ton of teams in the tournament just because that conference is so top heavy. Continuing to lose to good teams doesn't mean you are one, too. If they are one of the 34 best at-large teams, they will get in.


















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-17-2009 @ 12:41PM
MIKE said...
I am so tired of hearing about the Big East teams being so good...look at all of their records when they played out of conference teams. if you are good you don't lose to teams you are suppose to be better than. Get real all you "experts" if any conference gets more than six teams in the BIG SHOW it is only because ESPN and the media has accomplished what they have pitched all year...face it as the author of the article says "continuing to lose to good teams doesn't mean you are one, too...WELL SAID
Reply
2-18-2009 @ 8:36AM
Regis J. Goggin said...
If the BIG East isn't the best confercnce top to bottom then who is??? There are two or three teams in the BE who can be the national champion. They are not only the Beast's of the East but of all of college basketball. When one of these BE teams raise the trophy for the national championship.what will the "experts" say then? They will jump on the band wagon and mumble: "Oh maybe we were wrong in our limited views of the depth and power of this outstanding conference".
Reply
2-20-2009 @ 9:06AM
Shawn Gordley said...
Dayton is in the Atlantic 10 and are 4-0 against the Big East over the past three seasons: Marquette (2008-09 and undefeated), Louisville (2007-08 and #12), Pitt (2007-08, #5, undefeated), Louisville (2006-07 and finished 22-8). I wish UD /would/ face Syracuse in the tournament to show them defense like they haven't seen all year.
Reply
2-20-2009 @ 1:15PM
tpbhome said...
This Cronin guy is an idiot. The Big East has several very good teams but at least four A-Ten teams would be doing very well in the Big East (Xavier,Dayton,Rhode Island,St. Joes). Dayton beat Marquette at Marquette this year and Xavier beat his Bearcat team. A lot of those Big East teams refuse to play A-Ten teams on the road. On a rare occasion Pitt went into Dayton last year ranked # 6 and got blown out by 25 points. So much for the Big East magic.
Reply